DIBRUGARH, Nov 20: Assam Medical College and Hospital withdrew an advisory asking postgraduate trainees in its Department of Medicine to defer personal milestones, including marriage, until completing their residency. The order was withdrawn within hours of being issued on Wednesday after it drew objections from trainee doctors and doctors' bodies.

The advisory was issued by Dr Prasanta Dihingia, professor and head of the Department of Medicine. In a later notification, Dihingia said the earlier office order stood withdrawn with immediate effect.

At a glance

  • The Department of Medicine advised postgraduate trainees to defer marriage and other personal milestones until their residency was completed.
  • The notice said trainees should focus on clinical duties, patient care, academics and research.
  • Trainees and junior doctors protested on the AMCH campus, citing personal liberty.
  • Doctors' bodies said administrators should address duty hours and staffing rather than regulate residents' private lives.
  • The National Medical Commission's 2023 regulations provide postgraduate students maternity and paternity leave, among other entitlements.

What happened

The original order advised all postgraduate trainees, or PGTs, to defer personal milestones such as marriage until the successful completion of their residency tenure. It said their primary focus during the academic programme should remain clinical duties, patient care, academic pursuits and research requirements.

The notice also asked PGTs to adhere to the advisory positively. It was issued on departmental letterhead and carried a dispatch number.

Students and junior doctors staged a protest on the campus after the order was circulated. They argued that the instruction infringed on their personal liberty and could not be considered voluntary because it came from a department that dealt with leave, attendance and examination eligibility.

In the withdrawal notification, Dihingia referred to the earlier order on personal milestones during residency. He said it was cancelled and would be treated as withdrawn from the date of the later notice.

The Chief Minister's Office shared the withdrawal notice on social media. The move followed criticism from medical associations and trainee doctors.

Who said what

Dihingia said the advisory had been misinterpreted. He said it was intended as advice from a senior member of the profession asking trainees to focus on patient care and academics.

He said PGTs would continue to receive their annual leave entitlement under the rules. Some trainees had taken more leave than sanctioned, he said, but added that there was no question of punishment. He also said the AMCH principal had sought a written explanation from him.

The United Doctors Front said the wording described the notice as advice, but its official form and the department's authority over leave, attendance and examination eligibility meant residents would not see it as optional.

The group said marriage should not be viewed as a threat to patient care. It argued that the issue was workload and staffing, not weddings, and said women residents could face greater pressure. The body sought intervention by the National Medical Commission and Assam Health Minister Ashok Singhal.

The Federation of All India Medical Association condemned the advisory and demanded its withdrawal. Its president, Dr Atharva Shinde, said resident doctors were students undergoing training and no head of department or government had the right to impose restrictions on their private lives.

FAIMA said the withdrawal was welcome but the notice should not have been issued. It said administrators should regulate duty hours, not residents' personal lives, and warned that such directions could add to mental health pressures among trainees.

Background

The National Medical Commission's Post-Graduate Medical Education Regulations, 2023, provide postgraduate medical students maternity and paternity leave, casual leave, a weekly off, and reasonable working hours with adequate rest.

The United Doctors Front cited a 2018 Supreme Court ruling which held that the right to marry a person of one's choice was an integral part of Article 21 of the Constitution.

AMCH, established as the Berry White Medical School in 1900 and converted into a medical college in November 1947, is Assam's oldest medical college.

Why it matters for Assam and the Northeast

The controversy brought attention to the working conditions, leave rights and personal autonomy of postgraduate doctors at a major government teaching hospital in Assam. AMCH has long served as a medical education institution for the wider Northeast.

The episode also highlighted concerns over the demands placed on resident doctors, who balance patient care with academic and research work during their training.

What next

The Department of Medicine has formally withdrawn the advisory. The AMCH principal has sought Dihingia's written explanation, while doctors' groups have called for safeguards on residents' leave, working hours and personal rights.